Pea Gravel vs Decomposed Granite: Which Should You Choose for Your Project

Choosing between pea gravel and decomposed granite for your landscaping project can feel overwhelming. Both materials offer unique benefits, but understanding their differences will help you make the right decision for your specific needs and budget.

Quick answer: Pea gravel works best for decorative applications and areas with light foot traffic, while decomposed granite excels in high-traffic areas like driveways and walkways where stability matters most.

Pro tip: Pea gravel costs $30-35 per cubic yard and offers excellent drainage, while decomposed granite runs $40-50 per cubic yard but provides superior stability when compacted properly.

Let me walk you through everything you need to know about these popular landscaping materials so you can choose with confidence.

Understanding the basics of each material

Pea gravel consists of small, rounded stones typically measuring 3/8 to 5/8 inches in diameter. These smooth stones come from natural weathering processes and are available in various colors including grey, beige, brown, and even red options.

The rounded shape makes pea gravel comfortable to walk on, even in bare feet. Water flows easily through the spaces between stones, making it excellent for drainage applications. However, this same characteristic means pea gravel can shift and spread without proper edging.

Decomposed granite (often called DG) is a mixture of granite particles, fine sand, and silt that creates a more compact surface. When properly installed and compacted, it forms a stable, natural-looking surface that resembles packed earth.

DG offers good permeability while maintaining structural integrity under foot traffic. The material typically comes in earthy tones of brown, tan, and grey that complement most architectural styles.

Cost comparison and budget considerations

Your budget plays a crucial role in material selection, and there are notable differences between these options.

Pea gravel’s lower upfront cost makes it attractive for larger areas or tight budgets. Installation is straightforward since you simply spread and rake the material into place. The main ongoing expense involves adding fresh gravel every few years as stones gradually migrate or get embedded in soil.

Decomposed granite costs more initially and may require professional installation or equipment rental for proper compacting. However, once installed correctly, it typically needs less frequent maintenance than pea gravel.

Budget insight: Factor in edging costs for pea gravel projects, as proper containment prevents material loss and reduces long-term replacement needs.

Installation requirements and process

The installation process differs significantly between these materials, affecting both cost and project timeline.

Pea gravel installation starts with basic ground preparation including vegetation removal and leveling. You’ll need to install edging or borders to contain the material and prevent spreading. Metal, stone, or flexible plastic edging all work well for this purpose.

After spreading the gravel to your desired depth (typically 2-3 inches), rake it level and you’re essentially done. The loose nature of pea gravel means no compacting is required. If you’re considering using pea gravel as a base for pavers, keep in mind that its shifting nature may not provide the stability needed for such applications.

Decomposed granite installation requires more intensive preparation and equipment. After ground prep, you’ll spread the DG and then compact it using a plate compactor or hand tamper. This compaction step is critical for achieving the stable, firm surface that makes DG valuable.

Proper compaction may require multiple passes and light water misting to achieve optimal density. Without adequate compaction, DG can become loose and dusty, losing its primary advantage over pea gravel.

Best applications for each material

Understanding where each material performs best helps you match the right option to your specific project needs.

Pea gravel excels in:
– Garden pathways and decorative areas
– Around plants and trees as an attractive mulch alternative
– Drainage applications and French drains
– Play areas (comfortable for children)
– Areas with light foot traffic

Decomposed granite works best for:
– Driveways and parking areas
– High-traffic walkways and patios
– Sports courts and recreational surfaces
– Areas requiring wheelchair accessibility
– Slopes where erosion control matters

Consider your primary use when making this decision. If you’re creating a charming garden path that sees occasional use, pea gravel’s aesthetic appeal and comfort make it ideal. For a driveway that handles daily vehicle traffic, decomposed granite’s stability becomes essential.

The maintenance requirements also differ based on application. Pea gravel in decorative beds needs occasional raking and replenishment. DG in driveways may need periodic recompacting after heavy rains or extended use. For those working on specialized contractor projects, understanding these nuances becomes even more critical.

Application tip: You can combine both materials in larger projects, using DG for main traffic areas and pea gravel for decorative accents and garden features.

Both pea gravel and decomposed granite offer valuable benefits for different landscaping scenarios. Your choice ultimately depends on balancing factors like budget, intended use, maintenance preferences, and aesthetic goals. Pea gravel provides an affordable, attractive option for lighter applications, while decomposed granite delivers the durability needed for demanding installations. To explore more about the comprehensive benefits and uses of pea gravel, consider your specific project requirements and you’ll find the right material to create the outdoor space you envision.

FAQ